An Engineering Change Request (ECR) is a formal proposal used in engineering to modify a product, process, or documentation. It plays a key role in change management for engineering projects. This process involves carefully documenting, reviewing, and approving all updates before they are implemented. It helps maintain consistency, accountability, and proper oversight throughout the engineering project, reducing the chances of costly errors or miscommunication during implementation.
What causes an ECR?
An ECR can be initiated by a variety of factors that impact a product’s design, functionality, or production process. These triggers often arise from the need to improve performance, meet regulatory requirements, or address customer feedback. Sometimes, unexpected issues in manufacturing or quality can also prompt an ECR to ensure the product meets necessary standards. Common causes include:
- Design improvements or optimizations
- Customer requests or feedback
- Regulatory changes
- Safety concerns
- Cost reduction initiatives
- Manufacturing or quality issues
What should be in an ECR?
A well-prepared ECR outlines all the necessary details to ensure a smooth transition from proposal to implementation. It provides clarity to all stakeholders involved, helping them understand the scope, purpose, and impact of the proposed changes. A comprehensive ECR typically includes:
A detailed description of the proposed change
This section outlines the specific modifications, including technical specifications, drawings, or any relevant documentation. It should be detailed enough for all stakeholders to fully grasp the nature and scope of the change. Clear descriptions help ensure everyone understands what is being altered and how it will affect the overall project.
Justification for the change
This explains why the change is necessary. This could involve improving product performance, addressing safety or compliance issues, reducing costs, or meeting new regulatory requirements. Providing data or evidence, such as test results, customer feedback, or cost analysis, strengthens the justification and demonstrates the benefits of implementing the change.
Impact analysis on cost, schedule, and performance
This includes an assessment on how the proposed change will impact the project's budget, timeline, and overall performance. This analysis should cover both short-term and long-term effects, considering factors like material costs, labor hours, production schedules, and product functionality. Understanding these impacts helps stakeholders assess whether the change is feasible and how it might affect the project's success, ensuring informed decision-making.
Risk assessment
Identify any potential risks that come with implementing—or not implementing—the change. These risks could include technical issues, safety concerns, financial implications, or damage to the company’s reputation. For each risk identified, propose mitigation strategies to reduce or manage the negative impact. This approach ensures that any challenges associated with the change are understood and addressed proactively, minimizing disruptions and preventing unforeseen consequences during the project.
Required approvals
This section lists all stakeholders who need to review and approve the ECR. It typically includes project managers, engineers, quality assurance teams, and sometimes customers or regulatory bodies. Be sure to include a clear sign-off process to maintain accountability and ensure all necessary parties have reviewed and agreed to the proposed changes. This formal approval process helps prevent any oversight and ensures everyone involved is aligned before moving forward with implementation.
Implementation plan
This provides a clear roadmap for executing the change. It should include detailed steps for implementation, required resources, a timeline, testing procedures, and any necessary training or documentation updates. Consider how the change will be introduced and its potential impact on ongoing operations, ensuring a smooth transition without disrupting current processes.
How Bommer can help
The ECR process can be complicated, but BOM software like Bommer can make it easier by integrating your BOM alongside your design in your engineering software. Bommer helps you prepare the necessary documentation by ensuring your BOM is always up to date with your design, and by making it easy to generate the necessary inputs to create your ECR. This reduces errors and streamlines the ECR process, ensuring all proposed changes are fully and accureately explained, and thus can be managed and implemented smoothly. With Bommer, you can handle the complexities of change management more efficiently and with fewer headaches.
Autodesk Fusion 360
SOLIDWORKS